Overall I have decided that I am not the target audience for this book. While I agree with some of the points made, I feel like it is meant for women who believe that you have to get married in order to have a loving relationship with a man. Not that I don’t think marriage could be a wonderful thing or that I wouldn’t even try it myself. But marriage is not the technically the “End Result” that I’m looking for.
I think my thoughts towards the book fit into 2 major themes. One is that I feel like he writes about men as though they are black and white (and I don’t mean race). I feel like he takes all personality out of the men. Second, just because a man doesn’t do something mentioned in the book, doesn’t mean he doesn’t love you. Now, if he doesn’t do anything in the book, I would go with he’s not going to stick around long (nor should you let him). I would have felt much better if the book had started out with if your “prospective partner” does some of or all of these things he “could” bet your man.
Some things that I agree with:
Men’s love isn’t like our love: How true! Men don’t get all emotional and sappy when they think they aren’t loved…or as a way to show love.
The Three Things Every Man Needs (Support, Loyalty, and the Cookie): But, I also believe that all women need this too. I actually think this should be a statement made about people in general.
The words “We Need to Talk” Do Scare Men Shitless.
A man who introduces himself to you wants to sleep with you
Men are not mind readers and we do have to spell out our requirements/expectations (although I disagree about when this is appropriate)
Pretty much everything said about Mamma’s boys (and I’ve dated one so I know)
The men who cheat do so because:
They think they can get away with it
What’s happening at home isn’t “happening” like it used to
There’s always a woman out there willing to cheat with him.
The Five Questions you should ask him – although I don’t think you should use the answers to make an immediate decision.
The reasons for the 90 day rule…although not the 90 day rule itself…
Just Be a Lady. I completely agree that we can be strong, independent women while still being feminine.
We should not belittle our significant other when they are going through a rough time.
Men are simple creatures…Woman should be too.
What I didn’t agree with or understand:
If you have an ex that has started to “bother” you, and it is to the point that the new friend walks away…I don’t think this automatically makes him someone that isn’t a keeper for the woman. How long have they been seeing each other? I know that this is part of the 90 day rule and in that respect it is taking time into consideration. But depending on how severe the trouble with the ex is, I don’t know that 90 days is enough of time to know a woman enough to say you want to put up with the BS.
A guy who can’t hold is own when first meeting your kids isn’t necessarily a guy who is automatically one that you should not consider for the future. Maybe he hasn’t ever been around kids. That can be something to get used to. Now, if a month goes by and he still hasn’t warmed up to them AT ALL, then maybe he’s not kid material.
If this statement can be made about a man, “Because he wants you and he doesn’t want to loose you” why isn’t this enough. If he gives you everything you need (Support, Loyalty, and the Cookies) then why isn’t this enough? Why do you HAVE to get married? Is it the marriage that you are looking for or the support, loyalty, and the cookies?
“But let me tell you what’s really hard: dating/living with/having a baby with a man who has no intention of marrying you and eight years up the road, he walks out and you’re left to find a new man/pay all the bills after years of splitting them with someone else/raising those kids on your own”
If you are giving him the Support, Loyalty, and Cookies that are described earlier in the book…why would he leave?
This can’t happen with married couples? Statistics say that it does all the time
.
The reason I say that I’m not the target market for this book is because I am not “looking” to get married. I was at one time…I thought that the only way I could truly be an adult was to have my family: husband and kids. And, looking back on that time, I probably was the most unhappy in relationships that I’ve ever been. And I don’t think it’s because I was making all the mistakes that women do. Oh, I’m sure I made those mistakes, but that’s not what was making me unhappy. What was making me unhappy was that I wasn’t living life. I was trying to create it.
So now, I’m just decided to go with the flow. What happens happens. And if Josh wants to spend time with me, and I’m available, then we spend time together. This has been going on since September 2008 and our relationship has never been better. We spend more time together…and usually it’s his idea where before I was always the one to ask. And now we are living together…his idea, not mine. And he had no reason to believe that he was going to loose me if he didn’t. It was all his idea and it took me by complete surprise.
I have to agree more with Jenny McCarthy and what she said on Oprah regarding her relationship with Jim Carrey. Both of them at this point say that they will never marry again. And that they both know that the other is them because they want to be, not because of a marriage certificate.